It was a room full of men. In a year when inclusivity and gender equality have been buzzwords, an all-male delegation representing the Indian film industry meeting Prime Minister Narendra Modi to discuss issues plaguing the business -- that too twice -- has drawn considerable flak from women filmmakers and netizens.
"Would be great to have female representation in these delegations. It is 2018," tweeted Lipstick Under My Burkha director Alankrita Shrivastava, unleashing a stream of messages pointing at the apparent gender imbalance in the meeting.
https://twitter.com/alankrita601/status/1075035831369379842
The delegation, including the likes of Karan Johar, Akshay Kumar, Bhushan Kumar, Siddharth Roy Kapur and Prasoon Joshi, met PM Modi in Mumbai on Tuesday. They pitched for lower and uniform rates of GST for the entertainment industry in India, apart from calling for the development of Mumbai as the global entertainment capital, through various initiatives and proactive approaches.
But a big question it raised was -- "Where are all the women?" -- in what seemed like a reminder of a similar 'Modi and film fraternity delegation' meet held in October in New Delhi.
Alankrita told IANS: "I believe women are equal stakeholders in the film industry and overall in the Indian economy. Policies that concern the film industry should be discussed and shaped by collectives that have equal representation of women. We cannot just assume that only men somehow know everything and will decide everything."
She said that this held true for all industries and all kinds of panels and delegations. "It is 2018 and time is up on having all male groups leading the way. If we truly want a more equal world, we have to make proactive efforts towards creating it. And that will make us a genuinely progressive country," she added.
Producer Guneet Monga, whose co-production Period. End of Sentence, a short documentary, has advanced in the Oscar race, appreciated the government's interest in hearing out issues of the Indian film industry.
"It is great that the government and producers from film industry are meeting and I hope it helps the industry. It would have been wonderful for woman producers to be part of such initiatives too," Monga told IANS.
Acclaimed actress Tannishtha Chatterjee, who is turning director, said it would have been great to have a "more inclusive representation with women and film fraternity" from all other regions.
"Indian cinema is not only about Hindi films, considering the fact that this year's Oscar entry from India was not a Hindi film and directed by a woman," Tannishtha told IANS, pointing out at the lack of representation from the regional film industries at PM Modi's meeting as well.
Twitter remained abuzz with independent writers and columnists calling out the meeting for being "half-baked male-dominated".
Nevertheless, those who attended the meeting seemed satisfied and grateful to the PM.
Akshay tweeted: "Heartfelt thank you to the honourable Prime Minister Narendra Modiji for taking out time to hear us at length, discuss issues pertaining to our industry and assuring positive consideration of suggestions."
https://twitter.com/akshaykumar/status/1075066831604498432
Karan, head honcho of Dharma Productions, wrote: "It was enlightening to hear the honourable Prime Minister Narendra Modi shared his views on our industry's soft power status and the strength of our cinema... He gave our media and entertainment representatives a patient and solid hearing."
https://twitter.com/karanjohar/status/1075060793597677569
T-Series head Bhushan Kumar said: "It was my honour to be a part of an industry discussion with honourable Prime Minister Narendra Modiji. The film industry's contribution to the entertainment sector will see exponential growth in the coming years and will put India on the global map. Look forward to your continuous support."
https://twitter.com/itsBhushanKumar/status/1075072852666118144
These posts were accompanied by photographs in which the celebrities were all smiles meeting the PM.
On his part, PM Modi tweeted that the meeting involved "an extensive and fruitful" interaction.
"The delegation spoke about the strides being made by the film and entertainment industry, and gave valuable inputs relating to GST for their sector. Happy to see the passion among members of the film and entertainment industry towards the development of India. They talked at length about ways to further Mumbai's development, particularly with regard to making it a global hub for entertainment."
Actress Gul Panag voiced what many others felt: "Hope the delegation includes some women next time."
Not to forget, at the 49th International Film Festival of India this year, the Indian Panorama feature film jury comprised 12 people, but not a single woman. And the government-organised film jamboree also kept #MeToo discussions at bay.
